You are probably on this page because you want to compare the Singer 4411 to the 4423. You might also like to know a little more about the Singer 4432, 4452, 5532 and 44s.
So you are looking for a new entry level sewing machine and you just cannot make a choice. Completely understandable! You know what? Choosing a new sewing machine is not the easiest decision to make. There are all kinds of things to consider. For example, do you really need the machine with 800 different stitch types? (Here’s a tip, you don’t) Should you go for the upgraded model? You know, most of the extras aren’t necessary, but some of them – like the automatic needle threader – make your life easier.
Our goal is that by the time you reach the end of this page, you can decide if one of these machines is right for you.
Click here for a closer look at the Singer 4411
Click here for a closer look at the Singer 4423
Singer 4411 vs 4423 (See also 4432, 4452, 5532, 44s)
Appearance, size and construction
Side by side, these sewing machines are almost indistinguishable. They measure the same, 15.5 x 6.2 x 12 inches, and weigh the same – around 15 pounds. A closer look reveals a difference. You will see that the dials you use to select the stitch type are different. The 4411 has 11 stitch options to select from, while the 4423 has 23 different options. Other than that, there are no obvious differences.
The metal frame of these two machines provides increased overall stability and durability. In fact, it’s not just the frame that is metal, the gears and bearings are also metal. But unfortunately the shell is not made of metal, it is actually plastic. Some users point this out, but I have to say, what are you expecting at this price point?
The base plate (the area directly under the presser foot and needle) is advertised to be stainless steel, which is good. You definitely don’t want a plastic bed plate as it will likely wear out quickly with the feed teeth rubbing against it. But it’s also worth noting that this area they are referring to is just a 2 “x 2” square. The rest of the bed plate is plastic.
And then there are other plastic areas that make users scratch their heads, like the presser foot lift lever and the spool holder on top of the machine.
Note: The last two digits of these two patterns represent the number of stitches you can choose from.
We touched a little higher on the stitches. The Singer 4411 offers 11 different stitch types for you to choose from. These stitches include 6 basic stitches, 4 decorative options and 1 for the buttonhole. Now this offer is a bit anemic in my opinion. I think you’d better go for something that has a few more essential stitch options i.e. an option for a 3-stitch zigzag that’s good for working with a rubber band. Also, you may want more decorative stitch options. But for novice users, this may not be a problem.
The Singer 4423 offers 23 different stitch types. You get 6 basic stitches, 4 stretch stitches, a buttonhole stitch and 12 different decorative stitch options. I like that you have a lot more point options with the 4423. I think the 4423 offers a good starting point. While you don’t need a machine with a million different stitches that you definitely won’t be using, at the same time you might want more options eventually.
A variety of presser feet allow you to do many different types of jobs. Models 4411 and 4423 come with 4 different presser feet. Definitely enough to get you started. You get a general purpose presser foot that you will be using most of the time. You also have a buttonhole, zipper and button foot that will make it easy to add buttons to your clothes.
Threading is one of those parts of the seam that gives rise to complaints. You know, every machine has its own little nuances that can make threading easier or harder depending on how the machine is designed. Reading reviews is essential when looking for a new sewing machine. However, you must understand that threading the needle has a lot of room for user error. So when you come across reviews that report jams and “end up with a ball of thread,” consider that these users may have made a mistake or used poor quality thread or even a blunt needle.
From what I’ve read about the 4411, there are some users who have difficulty donning. What else? Some users say that the included instructions don’t quite explain how to thread the machine.
The 4423 comes with an automatic needle threader system designed to eliminate threading fatigue. This is a good option, but some people claim that they prefer to just manually thread the machine. So take this for what it’s worth.
I think I would prefer to have the automatic needle threader as an option although some people find it difficult to use it. This is definitely a plus for the 4423.
Singer 4411 – Read Ratings & Reviews
Singer 4423 – Read Ratings and Reviews
The 4423 scores high points in this category. You can create buttons simply and automatically in one step. It is a very convenient function which can save you a lot of time. The 4411, on the other hand, has a 4-step buttonhole process.
Feeding dog system
Feed dogs are important because they allow the fabric to move automatically through the presser foot and needle. The 4411 and 4423 have 6 feed dogs. If you want to do free motion quilting or other intricate work, there is a lever you can use to lower the feed dogs. A few users complained that when they lowered the feed dogs, they could not be raised again. This problem seems to be isolated to a few. I was not alarmed by this.
Intensive use …
I think it would be a bit of a stretch to consider either of these machines to be heavy in terms of build or performance. They both have 0.7A motors, which is pretty good for an entry-level sewing machine. But some users are put off by “making cheap porcelain” and others claim that “Singer is not what she used to be.” Personally, I think Singer always makes good products. But from what I found on these machines, they are not heavy duty machines.
I have come across stories of people who say that either of these machines can work through multiple layers of dense materials like jeans and fleece. I have even read articles about users who claim to use these machines for hours. But I also read stories about these machines seizing up. I think you can occasionally use these machines for an extended period of time. And I’m pretty confident that they can handle jeans and other heavy materials very well. But I don’t think they’re workhorses and it’s definitely not the kind of machine I would recommend for commercial application.
My advice is to forget about those hefty claims and watch these machines for what their price suggests. These are only entry level products and there is nothing wrong with that. If you choose one of these machines, accept the limitations. Do not have higher than deserved expectations for these machines.
Both of these machines come with many accessories including presser feet, seam ripper / lint brush, quilting guide, needles, bobbins, etc. From what I’ve seen, they come with the same accessories. However, there are sometimes different packages available. You can see the rest on the product description pages.
Other handy features you might want to pay attention to …
The free arm is a feature that lets you remove the arm, which is great when working with larger fabric items, think curtains and quilts. The transparent bobbin cover lets you see how much thread you have left on the bobbin without having to lift the cover. And of course, there’s the top-loading bobbin. Typically, sewing machine users like this feature because it is less complex than front loading the bobbin.
Both of these Singer sewing machines come with a 25-year limited warranty. Be sure to read it for more specific terms.
Similar sewing machines you might consider …
Singer 4432 – This model is like the 4423 (with the automatic threader, and the automatic one-step buttonhole) but it is programmed with 32 different stitches against 23. See the 4423 on Amazon.
- Singer 4452 – Just like the 4432, this one comes with 32 different built-in points. From what I find the only difference is that the 4452 comes with some bonus accessories. You get an even feed / step foot, non-stick foot, release plate, and sturdy size 16 needles. See the 4452 on Amazon.
- Singer 5532 – This model is exactly like the 4432 except for one important feature; adjustable foot pressure control. Automatic foot pressure control is important because when using it, you won’t have to worry about manually adjusting the foot pressure when changing the thickness of the fabric.
- Singer 44s – There is simply an aesthetic difference between the 44 and the 4423. Both have 23 different built-in stitches. See all 44 on Amazon.
Summary and recommendation
If I chose between the Singer 4411 and the 4423, I would definitely go with the more feature-rich 4423. Upgrades aren’t always necessary and aren’t always worth the extra cost. In this case, however, I think you’ll be more pleased with the improved choice.
For one thing, the 4423 comes with an automatic threader which should make what some find a very frustrating part of sewing a lot easier. Another very useful feature is the automatic one-step buttonhole process. I think the 23 point choices are very important because they give you a lot more options than the 11 offered by the 4411. You don’t need a ton of different points, but you probably want more than 11. .
The other machines on this list are also good choices. But overall, I think the Singer 4423 is the better choice considering the price, features, and availability.
Keep in mind that despite heavy marketing, these are actually entry-level sewing machines. Perfect for a beginner, a learning sewing machine, or a rescue machine if you will. Of course, advanced users could benefit from this, but don’t plan on running a high-performance sewing business using any of the machines listed on this page.
Singer 4411 – Check price
Singer 4423 – Check the price