Looking for a versatile production router that can be mounted on the worktable and still portable enough to be used freehand, the Porter Cable 7518 and Milwaukee 5625 are great choices. But who should you go to? Our Porter Cable 7518 vs Milwaukee 5625 comparison article seeks to help you make that decision. On this page, you’ll find everything you need to know about these two products, their specific areas of excellence as well as the drawbacks of some of their features, leaving you with a pretty good idea of which router is best suited to your needs.
Porter 7518 Cable – Click here to check the price
Milwaukee 5625 – Click here to check price
Comparison of Porter Cable 7518 and Milwaukee 5625 Routers
Design and construction
Both rotors are designed with large integrated molded handles for grip and ease of control. However, the Milwaukee 5625 offers more comfort and a greater degree of control, as its handles are padded and tilted slightly forward. The motor housing of the two rotors is made of aluminum. However, the materials used to make the motor covers of the two routers differ: the Milwaukee 5625 is made of ABS plastic, while that of the Porter Cable 7518 is solidly constructed of metal.
The Porter Cable 7518 is heavier than the Milwaukee 5625. This lightness of the Milwaukee is in part due to the fact that some components of the Milwaukee 5625 are plastic compared to the metal construction of the Porter Cable. Due to its lower weight, the Milwaukee is a better choice for users who prefer freehand.
Both routers have a large fixed aluminum base. The Milwaukee 5625’s base is also designed with a 21/2 inch clear polycarbonate sub-base.
Motor design, power and current
The Porter 7518 cable is rated at 3.25 hp, which makes it very efficient when used on hardwoods. It also comes equipped with a 10 foot long power cord ensuring that it can be used a considerable distance from the power source without the need for an extension cord. The cord has a coil spring guard at its base to prevent damage when the cord is pulled with considerable force.
The Milwaukee, on the other hand, is designed with a slightly more powerful 3.5 hp engine. The location of the Milwaukee’s power switch drew complaints from a decent number of users. They claim the switch is placed too far from the handles, making it virtually impossible to access the switch while holding the handles at the same time.
Both motors are designed to draw 15 amps of current.
Both routers can be table-mounted using their fixed bases or used as hand-held freehand routers. The Milwaukee 5625-20 comes with a standard bolt hole pattern, leaving users with no choice but to adjust their routers under the table. This can be corrected for your convenience by adding another hole in the insert plate. However, this is a compromise.
Variable speed and electronic controls
Both are variable speed routers, which means they have multiple speed options. This makes it possible to work on different jobs requiring different speeds while still being able to achieve the same level of precision. Both routers have the same minimum speed level of 10,000 RPM, but while the Porter Cable 7518 has a maximum of 21,000 RPM, the Milwaukee 5625 caps out at 22,000 RPM. Some users have complained that although the Milwaukee offered a higher speed, the speeds were not consistent and precise like the Porter Cable 7518.
They are also equipped with electronic controls to handle a wide range of bits and ensure smooth operation even when the router encounters a difficult spot or grain.
Click here for more details on the Porter Cable 7518
Click here for more details on the Milwaukee 5625
Included accessories and practical features
The Porter 7518 cable has a T-shaped handle attached to its base that makes it easy to loosen and tighten the collet when adjusting the depth of the drill bit.
The Milwaukee 5625 comes with two socket wrenches, a T-handle wrench, and a ½ inch socket. The included wrenches can be used to loosen the collet nut, in order to remove the collet and replace it with a new one.
Automatic release feature
Just like the Milwaukee 5625, the Porter Cable 7518 is also equipped with a 1/2 inch clamp. The difference however is that the Porter Cable 7518 is designed with an automatic release feature for its clamps. This feature eliminates the problem of stuck bits and saves time during projects. The clamp can also be replaced with other sizes of clamps such as ¼ inch and 3/8 inch clamps as desired. These replacement clamps, however, must be purchased separately.
Soft start function
The motors of both routers are designed with electric soft start. Manufacturers claim that this feature helps reduce starting torque, ensuring better control. Simply put, the soft start feature of both routers would prevent them from forcefully starting up when turned on and thus damaging the workpieces.
The Porter 7518 cable is designed with an internal circuit that shuts down the router once the motor begins to overheat. This preserves the life of the motor and also ensures the safety of the user. Motor overheating can occur when the router is used on wet wood or when a dull bit is used.
Both routers provide users with a 5 year warranty period.
Pros and Cons of Porter 7518 Cable
- Easy to use and control
- Automatic clamp release function
- Selected speeds are precise and consistent
- Designed for a smooth start
- Automatic shutdown when the engine starts to overheat
- Motor not as powerful as the Milwaukee 5625
- Its top speed is lower than that of the Milwaukee 5625
Pros and Cons of the Milwaukee 5625
- Better comfort and control
- Lighter than the Porter Cable 7518
- More powerful motor
- Has soft start function
- Offers more speed
- Placement of its power switch bothers users
- Does not have the automatic tightening function
- Speed selections are inconsistent and not that precise.
At regular price, you might find that the Milwaukee 5625 is priced higher than the Porter Cable 7518. A sale might change that, but at regular price, the features of the Milwaukee 5625 are not worth the extra expense. The choice also comes down to what you will primarily use your router for. If you need a reliable fixed-base router, the Porter Cable 7518 is the recommended choice. If you plan on playing freehand most of the time, you should probably get the Milwaukee 5625 because it weighs less.
Click here to see reviews, ratings and more for the Porter Cable 7518
Click here to see reviews, ratings and more for the Milwaukee 5625