An air compressor is essential if you are doing a lot of your own maintenance. Even more if you run your own business. In this article, we compare two very popular air compressor models, Makita Mac2400 vs Mac5200. These versatile machines are very similar in many ways, but we’ve outlined the differences below to help you make the best decision for you.
Makita Mac2400 – Click here to check the price
Makita Mac5200 – Click here to check the price
Makita MAC2400 vs MAC5200: Which of these air compressors is right for you …?
The MAC2400 is a 2.5 HP air compressor with two stacked tanks totaling 4.2 gallons. Its maximum pressure is 130 PSI. The MAC5200 is 3 HP with a 5.2 gallon tank. Its maximum pressure is slightly higher than that of the MAC2400 at 140 PSI.
The MAC2400 weighs 77 pounds, so it’s significantly lighter than the MAC5200 at 88 pounds. The MAC5200 also comes with quality wheels and a foldable handle that makes it easy to transport and store. The handle folds away near the tank for easy storage, and when deployed, the compressor can be transported as if placed on a cart. The MAC2400 and MAC 5200 both have an integrated roll bar. This means you don’t have to worry about accidental tips when going out with your air compressor.
Some users have had issues with the MAC5200’s wheels, claiming they are junky and plastic that can fail due to the weight of the compressor. Other users have suggested that the plastic wheels increase the vibration noise of the compressor and suggest replacing them with rubber wheels. Some users have reported that their compressor comes with rubber wheels, so it’s possible that Makita might change the design of the wheels.
The MAC2400 is significantly more economical than the MAC5200 at normal list prices. However, the MAC5200 is often available at a significant discount, making the two more comparable in terms of price.
Both compressors have cast iron cylinders which, according to Makita, “reduce wear and increase the life of the pump” and are removable for maintenance. Like any machine that you are going to be using regularly, having a design where maintenance is made easily accessible and straightforward means that you have a much better chance of ensuring that maintenance is done on time.
Makita announces both the MAC2400 and the MAC5200 have a “cast iron pump with [a] Big Bore cylinder and piston ‘. They say these offer “faster recovery time for improved performance”. Many users have found the MAC2400 and MAC 5200 to be reliable and not prone to failure. They also found these two models to be an improvement over previous Makita air compressors in terms of air movement and noise reduction.
While we’ve discussed horsepower above, the real important information isn’t so much horsepower as it is how much air each compressor can move. In fact, although the MAC5200 has 3 HP, its working HP is only 2.1 HP, the same as the MAC2400.
The MAC2400 has a 4.8 CFM at 40 PSI and 4.2 CFM at 90 PSI. The MAC5200 has a much larger CFM than the MAC2400 at 6.9 CFM at 40 PSI and 6.5 at 90 PSI. This means that the MAC5200 can push a lot more air than the MAC2400 at the same pressure.
The MAC2400 and MAC5200 both have two air outlets so that two tools can be used at a time. However, with the lower CFM, the MAC2400 won’t work with two aerators simultaneously like framing nailers, so if you have to use two, the MAC5200 might be a better bet.
The MAC2400 runs at 79dB according to Makita. This is because the pump operates at 1730 RMP, which decreases the operating noise and also, according to them, improves the durability of the pump. Many users have been impressed by the relative silence of the MAC2400. The MAC5200 is much louder with a decibel level of 90dB, and some users have found this to be a major drawback. While you must use hearing protection with both of these air compressors, the MAC5200 is loud enough that its placement can be a factor while you use it.
The MAC5200 has hooks on the handle to store up to 50ft of hose and hanging tools, which you might need to add extra bulk to this compressor. The handle allows the hose to be stored in both the upright and lowered position.
Click here for more details on the Makita Mac2400
Click here for more details on the Makita Mac5200
Both engines have oil lubricated pumps. This allows for a cooler operating temperature, reducing wear on parts and helping to extend the life of the air compressor. They also both have an oil view from the side so you can quickly assess the oil levels. The MAC5200 has the oil drain on the front of the pump, making maintenance quick and easy.
Both compressors also have ball valves for draining the condensate tanks. Makita thought about how to make them easy to use, so that no tools are needed to drain the tanks.
The MAC2400 and MAC5200 both have copper finned discharge tubes. This means that the compressor efficiently disperses heat, which helps reduce engine wear and prevents overheating. This also results in less water condensation in the tank, which will reduce rust.
The MAC5200 has built-in compressor storage for storing fittings and other accessories. This is a surprisingly overlooked feature in many other large compressors designed to be transportable.
One year limited warranty, 30 day money back guarantee if you are not satisfied, Makita will replace or refund it. The warranty requires you to return the entire air compressor to one of Makita’s authorized service agents for repair or replacement. Some users found this warranty process frustrating if they did not have an authorized service agent near them, as they had to ship the tool to the one closest to them.
Summary and recommendation
Makita generally has a great reputation and it is quite difficult to find users who have not had a great experience with their MAC2400 compressor. It has been easier to find users who are not completely satisfied with the MAC5200. However, this could be due to a number of factors. Many MAC5200 users are commercial users, while the majority of MAC2400 users are occasional home users. It’s easy to see why someone who uses a compressor every day would be more likely to experience issues and find issues with it. It’s also worth noting that there appears to be a slightly higher failure rate with the MAC5200. Since it is designed to be portable, it is possible that some of these failures could be triggered due to transport. Despite this warning, the vast majority of users are impressed with both the MAC2400 and MAC5200 and have not encountered any issues.
With that, your choice comes down to the consistency of the Mac2400 versus the portability and increased performance of the Mac5200. It all depends on what you need to do with your air compressor and how often you will be using it.
Click here to see the Makita Mac2400 reviews and ratings
Click here to see the Makita Mac5200 reviews and ratings